Gendered Narratives and Reactionary Newsjacking in Far-Right Communication

by | Nov 5, 2026

This interview is based on Benjamin Nangle and Leen d’Haenens’ article “Gendered Narratives and Reactionary Newsjacking in Far-Right Communication”.

Nangle, B., & d’Haenens, L. (2026). Gendered Narratives and Reactionary Newsjacking in Far-Right Communication. Fascism, 15(1), 116–159. https://doi.org/10.5117/fasc2026.1.007.meg.

This interview was conducted by Diana Wallens for the RRPN.

***

In your article, you discuss how “homonationalism” in which movements selectively invoke lgbtq+ rights to justify reactionary politics (particularly Islamophobic policies).  I am assuming that most of these movements are right-wing.  If so, how do they reconcile anti-lgbtq+ sentiments with the invocation of this group’s rights?   

It’s largely visible in right-wing discourse, though not confined to the far right. Puar, who coined the term, originally described how LGBTQ+ inclusion became part of US national self-image during the War on Terror, a move centrist governments and mainstream media also made. The far right has adopted it most aggressively in Western Europe, where defending gay rights against “backward” Islam has become a central claim of anti-immigration politics. 

The contradiction poses these movements little problem, because minority rights are secondary to the point. LGBTQ+ people appear as a vague marker of Western superiority, not as a constituency whose rights are defended in any concrete sense. The invocation is highly selective, usually centring a normative figure, typically a white cisgender gay man, and it sits alongside hostility to trans people, campaigns against “gender ideology”, and opposition to same-sex parenting and sex education. Tolerance becomes something “we” possess and an orientalised, backward “they” lack, a narrative that others migrants at home and dehumanises populations targeted by imperialist wars abroad, wars that themselves drive migration to the West. 

One example in our data was the invocation of gay rights in defence of Israel’s genocide in Palestine, through lines like “try being gay in Gaza, they’ll kill you”. The trope reduces Palestinians to a homophobic collective, erases queer Palestinians, and casts solidarity with Palestine, often voiced by queer people and their allies, as naive or self-defeating. It is a textbook case of divide and rule: setting marginalised groups against each other in defence of horrifying crimes, and forestalling solidarity between communities facing the same erosion of their rights and of the conditions they need to survive. 

For your dataset, why did you choose Instagram instead of other mainstream platforms?  

Partly it was practical: my co-author and I knew Instagram well, and my interest grew out of seeing acquaintances share far-right propaganda there. Such familiarity helps understand ironic, subcultural content, where meaning lies in in-jokes, dog whistles and references requiring domain knowledge. Reels also has huge reach but less scholarly attention than TikTok, possibly because of differences in researcher data access. Anecdotally, Instagram seems less tightly moderated. Much of what we found was strikingly blatant in its racism and fascism, whereas my TikTok-based work suggests far-right content there is less prevalent or better moderated. Users actually comment on this, and Instagram is jokingly called “my racism app”, and when TikTok briefly went dark in the US in January 2025, users migrating to Instagram were mocked as “not racist enough”. We haven’t compared the platforms systematically, so this is just a palpable impression. 

 In this dataset, one of your categories of “approved” masculinities consists of a recurring performance of ‘rational’, intellectualised masculinity. Do you think that this is the archetype that the so-called “tech bros” (e.g., Peter Thiel, Elon Musk) are attempting to project? 

I think the parallel holds. This archetype recurred strongly in our data: right-wing men presenting themselves as objective and rational while advancing pseudo-scientific or false claims and hateful positions. The tech oligarchs project something similar, and their wealth and technological achievements are offered as proof of superior intellect, licensing ill-informed and harmful pronouncements on politics, demography and society. Musk reasoning “from first principles” while amplifying far-right conspiracy theories, and Thiel’s cultivated contrarianism alongside openly anti-democratic politics both fit that mould. 

The archetype has a long history. Reactionary movements present ideology as objective truth and challenges to “natural” hierarchies, typically those advantaging white men, as irrational or perverse. Neoliberal technocracy acts similarly, using rational language to justify ideological choices like the brutal repression of migrants or austerity that devastates disabled people; Tymińska’s term “rationality management” captures this rhetorical strategy. In the 2010s the style was central to the online right, from Ben Shapiro and Charlie Kirk’s “facts don’t care about your feelings” to the trope of “owning” liberals and “hysterical” feminists, where reason is coded masculine and emotion feminine and left-wing. 

Your findings suggest that, in Anglophone communities, gendered narratives serve as a gateway for racist/xenophobic ones.  Why do you believe that this is the case? 

In our data these discourses overlap, as every far-right page we examined engaged in both gendered and racist or xenophobic content, aligning with wider research. Studies of Reddit and YouTube found substantial overlap between anti-feminist and far-right audiences, and survey research links sexism with nationalist and anti-immigrant attitudes. 

I think the connection works partly because gender is such an emotive, personal terrain. Many young men are frustrated at failing to live up to hegemonic ideals of masculinity, in relationships, work or status, and seek explanation and community. The far right offers both, validating frustration and redirecting it towards ideological targets: feminism for having “ruined” women, migrant men as sexual threats or rivals, falling birth rates as civilisational decline, within  overarching conspiracy frames. The sexual-threat frame dominates much of this discourse, and experimental work shows that depicting male immigrants as sexual predators can activate anti-immigrant attitudes rooted in paternalistic sexism. Personal grievance, often rooted in the socio-economic precarity of capitalism’s polycrisis, are transformed into collective, racialised projects. 

What type of gendered appeals do believe may be at the foreground of “female-coded, non-English, or regionally distinct accounts” (p. 151)?    

That note was about the black-boxed positionality of the research-persona method. We can’t know how the algorithm coded our accounts. Despite our efforts to keep them ambiguous, the platform likely inferred gender, location and other traits, and shaped its recommendations accordingly. A female researcher, or someone browsing from another country or in another language, would likely have encountered different cases. I can only speculate, but research suggests female-coded accounts might see more “tradwife” content, wellness and beauty aesthetics, appeals to motherhood and family, and above all women’s safety framed around migrant men, with femonationalist logic more prominent. Non-English or regional feeds maysurface locally inflected versions of these themes, tied to national histories, religious identity or domestic politics. A comparative design could fill that gap.  

***

Benjamin Nangle is a PhD researcher at KU Leuven working on the far right, discourses around migration, propaganda, and digital communication. He studies far-right persuasion strategies on social media and develops interventions to reduce youth susceptibility. He has published on the aesthetic and affective strategies of far-right propaganda in journals including New Media & Society, and a book with Palgrave Macmillan on the construction of hostility to migrants during the Lithuanian–Belarusian border crisis. 

Diana Wallens (she/her) is a Junior Fellow at the Canadian Institute for Far-Right Studies (CIFRS) and member of the Reactionary Politics Research Network (RPRN).  Her research focuses on transnational far-right networks as well as the intersection between technology and violent radicalization.  She has presented and co-presented projects at conferences across Europe, Canada, and the U.S., including the Prairie Political Political Science Association (PPSA) Conference & Indigenous Relationality Workshop, and the University of Bremen’s Gamevironments Research Day Workshop.  Her publications include articles for the Global Network on Extremism and Technology (GNET) and the Canadian Institute for Far-Right Studies (CIFRS) and book reviews for the RPRN website.   

Benjamin Nangle and Diana Wallens are members of the RPRN. 

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0