During the Brazilian elections on the 4th of October, far-right candidate Flávio Bolsonaro from PL (Liberal Party) received 56.1 million votes (47,03%), compared to 53.9 million votes (45,16%) for left-wing candidate Lula da Silva from PT (Workers’ Party). This is the smallest difference between two presidential candidates in a first round since promulgation of the 1988 Constitution. The son of ex-President Jair Bolsonaro, who was found guilty of plotting a violent coup and an assassination plan on Lula, follows the same ideology as his father but dresses it up in the blazer of moderation and liberalism.
A true wolf in sheep’s clothing, Flávio has claimed to want to change the constitution, reform criminal law and alter the judiciary, but remains ambiguous on what “re-democratising” Brazil actually means. As his father praises the likes of Augusto Pinochet, the former dictator of Chile who was indicted for crimes against humanity, and Colonel Ustra, a convicted torturer during the Brazilian military dictatorship, we can, however, paint ourselves a picture of what “re-democratisation” might look like. Changing the constitution was exactly what the military did after the coup, between 1964 and 1967, and taking inspiration from Trump, Flávio also leaves the door open to extending the presidential term.
So, what’s at stake? Everything. Will the Amazon burn, or will indigenous peoples be protected? Will the LGBTQIAP+ community be the target of violence, or will they continue to live? Will Brazil move closer to Israel and the US, or will it maintain its sovereignty? This is one of the most important elections for South America since the Brazilian military dictatorship ended in 1985, and surely the most important election for Brazil in the 21st century.
The Bolsonaros, who stem from a military background and are backed by the gun lobby, have been exposed for having ties with Rio de Janeiro militiamen but blame the left for being part of a “deep state”. So, let’s address the elephant in the room: corruption. This is, after all, what has fuelled the far-right’s anti-PT, anti-Lula campaign. In the last 20 years, the PT has definitely made mistakes, but Lula’s imprisonment during Bolsonaro’s presidency was controversial, to say the least. In 2018, Lula was accused of passive corruption and money laundering involving a triplex in Guarujá, which he admits he had visited once. There was no proof that Lula owned the apartment, but the lack of evidence was then taken as proof of an attempt to hide it, and he was found guilty. The Supreme Federal Court overturned his arrest and annulled his convictions in 2021 because the Federal Regional Court tried the case outside its jurisdiction. While PL was able to conduct a strong anti-PT campaign based on these corruption allegations, Flávio himself has been accused of laundering money in 2005, has accumulated numerous luxurious real estate properties far above what his wage could afford throughout his political career, and most recently, came under investigation for receiving the equivalent of $12 million from a banker at the centre of a corruption scandal to produce an unreleased movie titled “Dark Horse” about his father, Jair Bolsonaro. The corruption scandals that currently surround Flávio’s campaign are objectively larger than those currently surrounding Lula, but still, mainstream media promotes otherwise. The weaponisation of the far-right to use corruption claims against their opponents, while being at the centre of corruption scandals themselves, is a broader issue within Latin American politics. We see this with Milei in Argentina as well, where his long-lasting anti-corruption campaign was recently overshadowed by corruption claims against his own government.
That being said, we face a sad reality after this first round of elections. That is, 56.6 million people are willing to tolerate racism, transphobia, misogyny, and military authoritarianism in the name of allegedly, and hypocritically, “battling corruption” on the left. There are valid grievances too that are touched upon frequently by the far-right, such as high homicide rates of young people and rising femicides. What they fail to mention, however, are the ideologies that reinforce masculinity standards which legitimise aggressiveness and risk-taking behaviours that contribute to gender-based violence. The efficacy of violence prevention strategies is seriously compromised when hegemonic masculinity roles are ignored, at the same time as gun use is being promoted by the far-right. Violence against women is still a major structural issue that disproportionately affects historically marginalised groups and is characterised by racial and geographical disparities. Again, however, misogyny and anti-feminism are frequently promoted by the Bolsonaro family, as for example when Jair Bolsonaro told Maria do Rosario, an elected federal deputy, that “I would never rape you because you don’t deserve it.” The PT, on the other hand, under Dilma Rousseff, was the one who created the Femicide Act, which was enacted in March 2015, which officially criminalised gender-motivated homicide of women and which continuously addresses violence against minorities. The true challenge, thus, does not lie in finding solutions for these issues, but in convincing the population that the far-right is not, and never can be, the answer. We have to admit that Lula and his team were not aggressive enough in their campaign; they didn’t convince enough people that they could offer the much-needed answers to these problems. Lula himself has admitted that this has been the least organised campaign since 89’, adding that “usually we reap what we sow”. If Bolsonaro gets elected, the most populous country in Latin America joins a far-right surge backed by the United States. The coming weeks will decide the fate of millions, the fate of the queer community and the fate of all minorities in South America.
Lula was able to lift Brazil from the world hunger map twice and introduced the Bolsa Família, lifting millions out of poverty; these are well-known facts within the whole of Brazil. The world cannot act as if everyone who voted for Bolsonaro lacks information or decides irrationally. The left has to rejuvenate, come together, and revisit its strategies. The battle is not lost yet, and while increased representation of online-active left-wing candidates does not necessarily establish a broader shift towards the radical left, there is reason to stay optimistic. Three left-wing transgender women were elected and re-elected to the National Congress, while four others were elected as state deputies. Overall, votes on the left went mostly to radical leftist politicians, showing that a strong opposition is forming against the far-right. In Minas Gerais, for example, where Nikolas Ferreira de Oliveira of PL, a white gun enthusiast and close friend of the Bolsonaro family, remains the most popular politician, Elisa Santos Silva, a 21-year-old black member of PT, defied all odds and got elected next to him. On top of that, 33.5 million people abstained, the highest since 98’, so there is still room for gaining votes. Although there is still a chance that Lula wins the second round, he would, however, be stuck with the most reactionary Senate and National Congress Brazil has seen in the past few decades.
As Sabrina Fernandes has said, building on Gramsci’s work, “The old is dying, and the new is something we have to build.” In this interregnum, Bolsonarismo has risen, and the left needs to reinvent itself to stop it in its tracks by rethinking democracy beyond elections and countering the ideologies of the far-right. Defeating Bolsonarismo goes beyond voters’ motivations and requires more than just electoral victory or exposing its leaders’ contradictions. It has to question the power of the political and economic elites, their institutional accommodation, and most importantly: its authoritarian legacies. Bolsonarismo did not appear out of thin air with the rise of Jair Bolsonaro, as proven by Zanin. It is thus not just a matter of beating Flávio Bolsonaro in the coming elections, or any Bolsonaro that might follow for that matter; it requires a much deeper fight against the reactionary ideas that are embedded in Brazil’s historical structures.
In the case of Bolsonarismo in Brazil, the left should consider stopping its dependence on Lula’s legacy and rely on a larger-than-person project of a country as a whole instead. There are plenty of charismatic and promising leaders, even within the PT, such as the previously mentioned Elisa Santos Silva, who should be invested in and whose political careers should be promoted. But it goes beyond just that: the left should continue to consistently address the democratic deficiencies within its own institutions by exposing the economic and political elites who rule them; it should address the disconnect between elected officials and the people by having them leave Brasília consistently and talk to grassroots organisations in Brazil’s poorest regions personally; and it should go beyond just de-militarising the country, and completely restructure the way in which the government addresses the needs of minorities and children in dangerous situations and living conditions.
Flávio’s “moderate” presentation reveals how authoritarian projects adapt their language and strategies while preserving ideological commitments in a liberal democratic system. People in Brazil don’t fully trust liberal democratic institutions because of the country’s history of authoritarianism and imprisonment of democratic elected leaders like Dilma and Lula. The far-right is able to mobilise this and direct it against the left, whom they call “the establishment”. The people in Brazil have a saying: “Política, religião e futebol não se discutem”, or “Politics, religion and football are things not to be discussed”. They have been taught early on that you should not talk about the government, because the dictatorship that still lives in their minds would get you killed for doing so. This feeling still lingers on today, where people are scared to be close to politicians and politics in general. The left should therefore invest in political education for youth and teach them how to talk about politics and how to address their grievances to confront the historical structures through which reactionary ideas repeatedly acquire institutional legitimacy. One question, however, should be raised across the board: Should the left still be pursuing this fake dream of liberal democracy where authoritarianism is always just around the corner, or should they completely reinvent the way in which they conduct politics and protect the people?
Corneel Weyers is currently doing a PhD on the impact of reactionary populism on diplomacy in Brazil with MSCA Funding in the IDEoPOP network. Corneel is a member of the RPRN.
![]()
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0

